Supreme Court Appointments: The Issue of Prior Judicial Experience
During her confirmation hearings, Justice Kagan received relatively few questions about her lack of judicial experience. This contrasts with the appointment of Justice Sumption to the UK Supreme Court, which twice threatened to create a revolt in the Court of Appeal. Why was the experience of both nominees so different, and why was the American legal class willing to accept a judicial novice where their colleagues in the UK had shown such resistance?




